Friday, December 08, 2006

I am Canadian.

So it turns out I’m not fit to serve as Prime Minister. Or even as a lowly MP. I’m sure it’s no surprise to anyone who’s spoken to me for more than 30 seconds, but it’s the reason I’m not fit that’s got me in a bit of a snit. I was born in Canada, raised in Canada, educated and employed in Canada too. I’ve paid all my taxes in Canada to Canadian governments. I know the words to ‘O Canada’ in both official languages (did I mention I’m fluent in both of ‘em, too?), as well as the official bilingual version. I’ve lived in Canada my whole life, never leaving the country for more 6 weeks (and that was 20 years ago!). I won’t shop at Wal-Mart (preferring Zellers – it’s Canadian), and my paper cup says Tim Horton’s (only because it’s hard to find a Second Cup drive-thru). I love the Senators , Habs, and Rush (April Wine’s another story) and I’ve never been arrested (much less convicted of anything). So by now you must be wondering just what the hell (besides my attitude and propensity for cursing) could render me unfit to serve my country as a member of Parliament?

My dual citizenship, that’s what. You see, a few years ago, I decided to apply for Spanish citizenship. My family’s Spanish (I’m of the first generation lucky enough to be born in Canada). My dad came to Canada in the mid 50’s because Spain was a toilet back in those days, run by an embarrassment of a dictator. There weren’t any good jobs, and people were starving. My dad got a line on an opportunity to move to Canada, so knowing nothing about winter and lots about starving, he packed up and crossed the Atlantic to start a new life for his wife, daughter and extended family that he’d left behind while he set things up over here. Fast forward 20 years or so, and we’re all set up comfortably. Dad’s got a career, mom’s got food in the fridge, and sis has 3 siblings. Life’s good. And it’s ALL THANKS TO CANADA. You’ll have to forgive the caps, but capital letters is a good approximation of the importance my mom and dad placed on that statement. Everything we have is thanks to the opportunity Canada gave us. Our home, clothing, food, car, cottage, education, health care, all of it. Thanks to this awesome country that saw fit to welcome my family with open arms. To this day, my dad will not put up with anyone talking poorly of Canada. It’s a very good way to make him yell and turn his face red. Even now that he’s retired and moved back to Spain (the dictator’s dead, and there’s food a-plenty), my dad is a very proud Canadian, as he insists my entire family should be.

So why the dual citizenship? Well it’s for 2 reasons: First, it’s out of respect for my culture and heritage. My parents raised us as Spanish-Canadians. Before I started school, I was already reading and speaking in Spanish. We ate Spanish food (as well as Canadian) at home. Our holidays were a mash-up of Canadian and Spanish traditions, we vacationed in Spain. I’ve always identified very strongly with both my Canadian identity and my Spanish heritage and it’s important to me that my future kids know where their history is and that they’re Spanish as well as Canadian. The passing of my mother and the fact that my father’s getting older and may not live to see my kids (at the pace I’m going) were 2 factors that made me really think about my heritage, how much it means to me and how important it is for me to pass it on to my children. And as the older generation slowly but certainly passes away, the direct links to my ancestral homeland become fewer and fewer. So I sought to reinforce those links by becoming a Spanish citizen.

The other reason is a matter of practicality. Spanish citizenship is European citizenship, and having that, I can work anywhere in Europe. No jumping through hoops (well not as many). While I currently have no plans to leave Canada, it seems common sense to keep as many doors open as possible. If I were to be given an incredible job opportunity in Europe, it’d be nice to know that I can accept and pursue it without having to go through all sorts of immigration hassles.

So that’s all there is to it. There’s no nefarious plot. No secret loathing of Canada. I’m not spying for anyone. Culture and opportunity. The only 2 reasons I have dual citizenship. No big deal? Not so fast.

Seems we have a new Liberal leader, and he’s not the guy the Tories were expecting to win the leadership. The Conservatives were all set with their planned attacks for Michael Ignatieff or Bob Rae, but they didn’t have anything they could really nail Stephane Dion with. So Ezra Levant, as big a steaming turd disguised as a human being as you’ll ever find, went to work. Without anything of real substance to nail him on, Ezra focused in on the fact that Dion has dual French/Canadian citizenship. And the media decided that without anything else to question him over, they’d also pursue the dual citizenship storyline. Apparently, if you have dual citizenship, you’re not sufficiently loyal to Canada and are plotting to somehow destroy the country from within. The NDP have, in their constant battle for airtime and attention, decided to jump on and question Mr. Dion as well. And much to my chagrin, Mr. Dion has said that if it’s a problem, he’ll renounce his French citizenship. What he should have said was “I’m Canadian first and always, and anyone who says that my dual citizenship compromises me and my ability to serve Canada is nothing but an ignorant xenophobe.” Case closed.

So for the past few days, I’ve been seeing the attacks, and the snide remarks all over the web and in the papers. I take them personally because I love Canada, and for someone who’s never even met me to say otherwise for no other reason than because I have a Spanish passport is disgusting beyond words. I’m Canadian. I love Canada. I shouldn’t have to say that, but lately, a few ignorant shit-disturbers have made it necessary for me to state that for all to see. For all of you who say that I shouldn’t have dual citizenship, Well I’m sorry. I’m sorry that I take pride in my heritage and culture. I’m sorry that my family hasn’t been here for 200 years. I’m sorry that I decided to do what I could to give myself as many options for my future as I could. But I’m not sorry for having 2 passports. And I never will be. For those of you who say that I’m somehow not fit to serve in Parliament, well you’re wrong. I’m Canadian. With all the rights, responsibilities and privileges that go with that. And it’s my right to serve my country in Parliament if I so choose. And to those who would take that right from me, and this means you Ezra Levant, well I’d like to see you try. C’mon. Say it to my face. I dare you.

And for the NDPers and tories who have played along with this shameful farce? Shame on you for disgracing parliament with this hateful, xenophobic line of attack. Have you no decency? Especially the NDP, who for a long time have had the support of immigrants and dual-citizens to thank for their few accomplishments. I will never, ever vote NDP or Conservative. Not now that they’ve made me feel a second-class citizen in my own country. And if a law is ever passed that would take away my dual citizenship, or prevent me from enjoying the rights and freedoms promised to all Canadians, well it’ll be the Canadian passport that I’ll hand in. I won’t need it as the Canada I know and love will have ceased to exist, replaced by a suspicious, xenophobic, closed minded ignorant imitation of Canada. One which I’d be embarassed to be a citizen of.

33 Comments:

Blogger Red Tory said...

I second your emotion.

You know my feelings about this matter. It's a classic case of aa "false dilemma" that's been fabricated by Ezra Levant and then perpetuated by the CPC.

2:26 PM  
Anonymous AM said...

jdave that is a fine piece of writing you have posted there. It was stirring. I am stirred.

2:28 PM  
Blogger Nicole said...

Sorry to hear about your Mother.

I can totally understand your sentiments.

You do realize that this post was rather, er, touching, right?
Has 34 MELLOWED you??? :)

First RT can half\ass have his heart start to beat like the Grinch's and now you...
I am off to add some rum to my eggnog....hope Captain Morgan is waiting under the mistletoe too.....

2:47 PM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

Nic:

Thanks for the kind words....

Mom's been gone for years now, but Christmas gets harder every year....

I don't think I've mellowed...maybe I just need more coffee....
;)
And it certainly wasn't my intention to write a 'touching' post....Sometimes that's just the way things come out though.....

And I had no idea you had a thing for gay pirates....

3:00 PM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

RT: Don't forget, the NDP have done their share of perpetuating too...Something I found shocking and won't soon forget....

3:01 PM  
Blogger Nicole said...

And I had no idea you had a thing for gay pirates....

Well..we are like one big family now...thought I would share my secrets too....imagine MY surprise when you opened up about the blow up goat and the tub of ass butter....how is gabby anyway???
lol

3:39 PM  
Blogger Nicole said...

Mom's been gone for years now, but Christmas gets harder every year....

I don't think I've mellowed...maybe I just need more coffee....
;)
And it certainly wasn't my intention to write a 'touching' post....Sometimes that's just the way things come out though.....



How long has she been gone now? I imagine the holidays really make you aware of her physically not being there. Do you ever do something to specifically remember her?

Incase the old JDave plans to someday spawn, why don't you start a little journal about your Mom...do it know while you Dad is around to help with some details. Espcially incase you ever have a little girl...we are NOSY creatures and she will want to know as many simple little details about her grandmother as possible. Plus, it will be nice for you to have for yourself, just for days when you want to really think about your mom.
damn you JDave, now you have me typing with tears dripping all over the damn place!!!

I have an angel that I set out specifically for my cousin. I have even named the angel my cousin's name and when I set her out now, I think of my cousin everytime I look at the angel. Which is kind of ironic, as she certainly was NO ANGEL!! :)
But to me, it brings me peace as I hope my cousin is in a better place and can be at peace with herself.

and lastly, about the touching posts coming out every now and again...it takes a big man and a good man to show his heart and it is also good for the soul. Don't worry, your hard ass image is safe with me...you big softie!!! lol

ps..VERY intriguing about the SPANISH background......
Si Si Senior:-D

3:50 PM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

Nic:

Well that's certainly a stronger response than I was expecting....

Mom's been gone for almost 13 years now... I don't do anything in particular to remember her because pretty much everything about Christmas reminds me of her...

I like your journal idea though...definitely something to consider....

Sorry I made you cry...
;)

9:56 AM  
Blogger BLUE705 said...

Many people are proud of their heritage--I don't know of many who apply for citizenship to the nation where their parents came from. It is your choice but I do think that choice would make a huge issue if you were to be PM (much greater than a Canadian/French citizenship). The PM represents Canada. If you came to a disagreement between Spain and Canada where would your loyalties lie? If you say Canada, then your citizenship in Spain is just a piece of paper I guess.
You also misunderstand why I am upset with Dion's citizenship. If you were a Conservative Party leader you better bet your bottom dollar, Dion would have an issue with your citizenship.
I am not upset because there is nothing else to "get him on". I do not see this as nothing that I am going to feign anger about. It is an issue with me--honestly --really--truly--it is an issue.
How can he renounce it if it's only becasue he's made to? What kind of renouncing is that?

10:46 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This dilemna became apparent when we were compelled to send Navy vessels to Lebenon. The problem is that Canada has a law permitting citizens to hold dual citizenship. Without the law, we will no longer be considered Hotel Canada, where folks, still loyal to their parents' homelands, will no longer have the option of "keeping doors open" or other such nonsense. This is Canada, a country, not a club.
ANd btw, not shopping at Wal-mart and buying coffee at Tim Hortons doesn't define you as Canadian. It just defines your choices as a consumer. Learn something about Canada's past and how this counrry came to be what it is today and then maybe you'll appreciate that pasport a little better.

12:19 PM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

blue 705:

"Many people are proud of their heritage--I don't know of many who apply for citizenship to the nation where their parents came from."

--That's funny. I know a lot, starting with between 10 and 20 people in my own family. Then there are my friends of Italian, British, and Portuguese backgrounds, all of whom have gotten their citizenships in the countries their parents came from.

It is your choice but I do think that choice would make a huge issue if you were to be PM (much greater than a Canadian/French citizenship).

--Why exactly? What have I done to make it an issue?

The PM represents Canada. If you came to a disagreement between Spain and Canada where would your loyalties lie?

--Well let's see if we can answer this by looking at my original post:

"Everything we have is thanks to the opportunity Canada gave us. Our home, clothing, food, car, cottage, education, health care, all of it. Thanks to this awesome country that saw fit to welcome my family with open arms."

Where do you think my loyalties lie? With a country across the ocean, that I have historic ties to, but no practical ones? or with the country that has sheltered, cared for, provided for and educated me? You'll forgive me if I consider your question a particularly stupid one.


If you say Canada, then your citizenship in Spain is just a piece of paper I guess.

--Did you read my post at all? Make it past the headline? I won't repeat myself, but suffice to say, my Spanish citizenship is far more than just a piece of paper, for all the reasons I mentioned.

You also misunderstand why I am upset with Dion's citizenship. If you were a Conservative Party leader you better bet your bottom dollar, Dion would have an issue with your citizenship.

--Really? Howcome nobody's raised a stink about the Conservative MPs who have dual citizenship? At any rate, this part of your comment betrays your true feelings; You don't care about Dion's dual citizenship, you're just playing gotcha, with the one thing that you can use. Pretty weak, IMO.


I am not upset because there is nothing else to "get him on". I do not see this as nothing that I am going to feign anger about.

--Yes you are. You just said "If you were a Conservative Party leader you better bet your bottom dollar, Dion would have an issue with your citizenship." This leads me to believe that your position has less to do with concern for Canada, and more to do with 'getting them dang Lib'rals!!!'

It is an issue with me--honestly --really--truly--it is an issue.
How can he renounce it if it's only becasue he's made to? What kind of renouncing is that?

--Which is why I think it's ignorant, petty and xenophobic to make these kind of stupid demands. Why don't you focus on real issues instead of inventing false ones for no other reason than to demonize your imagined enemies?

8:57 AM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

Anonymous:

This dilemna became apparent when we were compelled to send Navy vessels to Lebenon.

--The problem wasn't with dual citizenship. The problem is with people who travel to places they should know better than to travel to, and when things go wrong, they expect our government to rescue them.

The problem is that Canada has a law permitting citizens to hold dual citizenship. Without the law, we will no longer be considered Hotel Canada, where folks, still loyal to their parents' homelands, will no longer have the option of "keeping doors open" or other such nonsense. This is Canada, a country, not a club.

--This isn't 'Hotel Canada'. And the door I have kept open is in Europe. Not in Canada. I've never left Canada. Did ANYONE read my post all the way through before commenting?


ANd btw, not shopping at Wal-mart and buying coffee at Tim Hortons doesn't define you as Canadian. It just defines your choices as a consumer.

--You're right. It doesn't defiine me as Canadian. But my choice as a consumer is to patronize Canadian businesses over foreign ones whenever possible. And the reason for that? Because I'm LOYAL TO MY COUNTRY. Understand? I choose to keep my money in Canada, benefiting Canadians over foreigners. It may be just a consumer choice, but it's one I've made with my country and my fellow citizens in mind.

Learn something about Canada's past and how this counrry came to be what it is today and then maybe you'll appreciate that pasport a little better.

--Quite the assumption you've made there. That I don't know about MY country's past and how MY country came to be. Truth is, I probably know just as much as, and probably more about Canadian history than you do. And as for appreciating my Canadian passport? Well, you don't know what you're talking about, and I seriously doubt you read my post. Good day, Oh glorious anonymous poster. your comments are welcome and appreciated.

9:08 AM  
Blogger Nicole said...

Especially what you have written regarding your family, makes it very simple for anyone to understand EXACTLY why you would value and maintain your duo cit.

Here where I live, we have an annual multicultural event called MOSAIC, that celebrates cultures, ethnic foods, traditions, dancing, songs, languages, etc. You purchase your " passport" which I think is 10 bucks and it gives you a 3 day pass into each pavillion.
It is a great way to experience all different cultures and backgrounds. When you talk to the people at each pavillion, whether it be to buy a drink, food, a gifty type item, or just to ask questions, you can see how proud these people are of their backgrounds. ALL of them will tell you that Canada is the best country to live in, but they will always love and hold dear to their hearts the love of their homelands.
Our past is part of who we are.


oh yeah, JDave, sometimes I call MY anonymous..... aYAWNamous. Tis rather sad to try to be clever...hence the word..TRY :)

12:51 PM  
Blogger Nicole said...

Ps..you don't have to apologize when you make someone cry for melancholic reasons, or happy tears...

RT and I have both had a good ole cry over his dear Mum....I can't think of nicer reasons to have to cry, then remembering and sharing stories about loved ones.

1:10 PM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

nic: you're a sweetie...

1:22 PM  
Blogger Nicole said...

ah, Jdave, didn't you hear...ANON dropped in and told me I am not that sweet...

but it means something coming from you.

Jeez, Christmas, or maybe it was Spain, must have given you a little ZAZU... I am seeing a WHOLE new side to you...and I like both sides!!

maybe it was that leopard banana hammock that did it...hmmmmm

1:30 PM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

I don't think I've changed...I just don't like having my patriotism questioned or my rights as a Canadian challenged.

1:32 PM  
Anonymous ellie said...

yup...you have an anon here too!!

You know you don't have to post anon... you can use the other option to put your name and website...

geesh!

2:02 PM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

anons are welcome here...every circus needs a monkey...

2:08 PM  
Blogger Nicole said...

jdave34 said...
I don't think I've changed...I just don't like having my patriotism questioned or my rights as a Canadian challenged.



I never said CHANGED...you are still you..come on man, there is only ONE JDAVE34!!

I said I am seeing a whole new side of you...the softer, more feeling side...ok, I am sure you are hating this...
but last week you told me that I was a dear and now today a sweetie...I am sure that there are people out there that would keel over reading your kind words...lol, not that I haven't always kinda known that you had a sweet side yourself.

2:21 PM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

Nic: "I am sure you are hating this..."

More than words can express.....lol

2:37 PM  
Blogger Nicole said...

More than words can express.....lol


ok, we will draw the line...it's not like I was going to talk to you about my period or something...geesh!!! ;-)

Heads UP...CBC tonight is playing the Grinch and then Frosty...I just may have to watch, I suddenly am feeling very festive. You watch too...I just know that the Grinch will grow on ya...your heart may grown an inch or two, too!!!

4:07 PM  
Blogger Zac said...

Jdave, you need to post more often. Great article.

8:10 PM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

zac:

I'm planning on it...There are changes afoot....
;)
keep checking in

8:27 AM  
Blogger Nicole said...

up next...Christmas carols....


I notice you ignored my period comment...good call, that would actually make us be " talking about it!!!" ;-)

9:14 AM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

I don't often comment at night, and like most other men, am clueless and more than a little frightened by that 'time of the month'.

I'll quote Mr. garrison from South Park:

"Children, never trust anything that bleeds for 5 days without dying."

9:34 AM  
Blogger Nicole said...

lol !!!







PIG :)

9:56 AM  
Blogger Nicole said...

Well I hope you are happy....on my blog, the thread called The Bonds of Friendship, I have a new poster...she says the best word for cooch, is PISSFLAPS...and she wants me to listen to some camel toe song...left instructions...warned me about porn popping up....you listen to it and screen the porn for me.

So, now word has gotten out and my blog is infamous for COOCH COMMENTS....thought that this would bring a tear to your eye...

her "name" is ice, but her blog is called Princess DBT...wonder if she is any relation to the DBT that frequents RT's...

11:12 AM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

"Princess DBT...wonder if she is any relation to the DBT"

Drag queen alter-ego is my guess

11:27 AM  
Blogger Nicole said...

Hey, where did your other posts go???

I wanted everyone to be able to read my comment to you about the MILE HIGH CLUB, someday when you are rich and famous!!!

2:44 PM  
Blogger jdave34 said...

I toasted em....I'm building a second blog that's gonna be for all my goofy stuff...

It's gonna be called Jose Machismo's Rancho Cabeza

This one's gonna be for political/social/semi-serious stuff...

2:50 PM  
Blogger Ice said...

lol @ drag queen alter ego.

Close but no banana : )

3:59 PM  
Blogger Nicole said...

I left you a comment on Jose.

11:01 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home